Handyman vs. Contractor: Cost Differences Explained

Handyman Hank
Jan 17
3 min read

Updated: Feb 18

When something breaks, needs updating, or just isn’t working quite right in your home, one big question comes up fast:

Do I need a handyman — or a contractor?

The answer matters, because the cost difference can be significant. Hiring the right professional for the right job saves money, time, and frustration. Let’s break it down.

What’s a Handyman?

A handyman typically handles small to medium repairs, maintenance, and installations, such as:

Drywall patching
Door and trim repairs
Fixture replacements
Caulking and sealing
Small carpentry projects
Minor plumbing or electrical tasks (where allowed)

Handymen usually work hourly or by small project, making them ideal for quick fixes and ongoing home upkeep.

What’s a Contractor?

A contractor is typically hired for large-scale or specialized projects, such as:

Major renovations or remodels
Structural changes
New construction
Roof replacements
Large plumbing or electrical jobs requiring permits

Contractors often manage crews, pull permits, and coordinate inspections — which adds complexity and cost.

How the Costs Compare

Here’s where the difference really shows.

Handyman Costs

Typically charged hourly or per small job
Often more affordable for short or simple projects
Minimal overhead means lower rates
Great value when bundling multiple tasks into one visit

Best for homeowners who want things fixed efficiently without overpaying

Contractor Costs

Usually priced by project, not hourly
Higher labor costs due to specialized licensing and crew size
Permits, inspections, and project management add to the total
Minimum project sizes often apply

Best for large, complex jobs where permits or specialized trades are required.

Why Hiring a Contractor for Small Jobs Can Cost More

Many homeowners assume a contractor is the best option — but for small repairs, that can backfire financially.

Contractors often:

Have minimum job fees
Prioritize large projects over small ones
Charge more to cover administrative and overhead costs
Subcontract small tasks at a markup

For simple repairs, this can mean paying far more than necessary.

When a Handyman Is the Smarter Choice

A handyman is usually the better option when:

The job doesn’t require a permit

No structural changes are involved

The work can be completed in a few hours or less

You have multiple small tasks to tackle at once

This is where homeowners often see the best return on investment.

When You Should Hire a Contractor Instead

You’ll likely need a contractor if:

The project involves load-bearing walls
Major plumbing or electrical systems are being altered
Permits and inspections are required
The job spans weeks instead of hours

In these cases, the higher cost often comes with legal protection and specialized expertise.

The Bottom Line

Choosing between a handyman and a contractor isn’t about cutting corners — it’s about matching the right professional to the right job.

Handyman: lower cost, faster turnaround, ideal for everyday repairs

Contractor: higher cost, necessary for major renovations and permitted work

For many homeowners, especially those maintaining older homes or preparing to sell, a handyman can handle 80–90% of common repair needs at a fraction of the cost.

Handyman vs Contactor Cost - Need Help Deciding?

If you’re unsure which route makes sense for your project, a professional handyman can help assess the scope and let you know if a contractor is truly needed — saving you time and money upfront.